Outline of John 5
Introduction. Until now the Gospel of John has shown Jesus in relationship with individual people, or with his disciples or family (his mother). But now the scene broadens. Jesus begins to be in conflict with a group of people, the Jews, especially the Pharisees and the teachers of the Law (Scribes).
The time. The chapter begins with the information that this was the time of a “feast.” But no specific feast is mentioned. The alternative reading “the” feast, is doubtful and does not settle the question. John gives us some details, but not all that we would, perhaps like. Nonetheless, it is all we need.
Jerusalem seems to be standing at the time of writing (dating the Gospel before 70 AD), see 5:2, “Now there is in Jerusalem the Sheep Gate . . .” (Leon Morris, John, ad loc).
The chapter breaks into two sections. The healing of the paralytic by the Pool of Bethesda, and the conflict with the Jews over the Sabbath.
Part 1 — The healing at Bethesda.
- The man who was healed by the pool of Bethesda had been ill a long time. For 38 years he had been coming to the pool waiting for the waters to be stirred so that he might receive healing. The myth or legend of the stirring of the waters was well-known, and it is a point of pity toward the man so-long-ill. The language used to describe the man may infer or imagine that he was injured and became a paralytic as a result of the injury. But the text is notably absent on the cause of his paralysis, just the length of it, pointing to the protracted time of his malady. The age of the man is not given, only the length of the time of his suffering.
- It is to be noted that the man did not express any faith in Christ, nor knowledge of him other miracles or his competency to effect healing of his organic disease. The man seemed not to know anything about Jesus in terms of his name or family, or spiritually as one who was a worker of miracles. It is most amazing that the man didn’t stay with or follow Jesus after he was restored.
i. It could be that the healing put new responsibility on him.
ii. It could be that he had learned to be passive and a beggar and that he was not able to function as one who was able to provide for himself.
iii. It appears that his lack of faith was profound (see 5:16, his betrayal of Jesus).
- The absence of faith in the paralytic is all the more interesting because it was Jesus who came to the man, not the other way around. Jesus came and asked the man if he wanted to be healed.
- Faith was not the cause of his healing. He did not seek healing, but pity from Jesus, “there is no one to help me get into the water.”
i. Many are healed of terrible diseases, they call upon God to heal them, and they are restored, yet they do not believe.
ii. His belief in the “stirring of the waters” myth (hope) seemed to have been his only hope for healing. When Jesus comes to him and heals him, he doesn’t have any way to interpret what Jesus did for him. Jesus didn’t stir the waters. Jesus didn’t carry him first into the pool. Jesus didn’t do any of the things the man believed would bring him healing. Jesus simply healed him.
- The healing of the paralytic set in motion the totality of events that resulted in the death of Jesus.
i. The conflict with the Jews about carrying a load on the Sabbath, and the ensuing defense that Jesus gives to them of his work, his person, of his relationship to the Temple, to God the Father and to the Father’s work, all created the set of charges that would follow Jesus until he is formally charged and then executed for blasphemy.
ii. The references to the murderous inclinations of the Jews toward Jesus found in John’s Gospel: 5:18; 7:19, 25; 8:37, 59.
iii. The greatest irony of Jesus’ death is that he is executed for the sin of blasphemy because he claimed “he was equal with God,” which he was.
- The distinction that Jesus made of his relationship with the Father was that he was “my Father.” The Jews spoke of God with very careful language, as “Our Father,” — the same name by which he taught the disciples to pray to God in the Lord’s Prayer.
- The claim that Jesus was in a special relationship to his Father in Heaven was a claim of equality with God, of being of the same family and origins as God. It was most offensive for the Jew to address God in this manner.
- Jesus, at the end of John, employs the same language of intimacy with the Father, and with God.
- He joins those who have faith in Jesus in that circle of intimate relationship with God as a personal and familial connection.
- Jesus said to her, “Do not cling to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father; but go to my brothers and say to them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’” (John 20:17 ESV)
- Addressing God
- The paralytic proved himself to be “the worst sort of character.” Immediately after being found by Jesus after he spoke with the Jews about why he was carrying his bed around on the Sabbath, he immediately returned to the Jews and told them it was Jesus who had healed him.
i. There was no appreciation for the healing expressed. There was no sense of loyalty or desire to protect Jesus from the religious authorities; he was immediately and continuously loyal to the Jews and their leaders.
ii. This even though Jesus warned him (5:15) about worse things happening to him, Jesus said to him, “Sin no more, that nothing worse may happen to you.”
- The Jews are directly addressed from 5:19–47. The teaching Jesus gives them about himself is clear, challenging, confrontational, and glorious.
- Notes on John 5:19-47
- 5:19 Jesus declares that he is only “doing what the Father is doing.” This is the way in which Jesus decided what he would do. If he saw the Father working, he would work there. If not, he would not. This is associated with Jesus’ prayer, “Not my will, but yours be done” see Matthew 26:39; Mark 14:36; Luke 22:42.
i. The revelation to the Jews is quite stunning. These men have been rising in their opposition to Jesus even in these early days of his ministry and yet he addresses them with many doctrines and teachings about himself, his relationship with God the Father, and his own Person and work.
ii. Because he is doing what the Father is doing, any complaint about his work becomes a complaint about the Father’s work and a criticism of the Father.
- 5:20 The love of the Father for the Son and the work of the Son to reveal all the works of the Father to those who have eyes to see it.
i. And there is promise of far greater miracles that will be seen in the future. Scholars often see this as a cryptic reference to the resurrection, though it is impossible to know exactly what miracles Jesus had in mind at this early point.
ii. The end of these miracles is that they may “marvel” at what he has done.
- 5:21 The work of resurrection (spiritually and physically) is both the work of the Father and the work of the Son of God.
i. The sovereignty of the Son is laid out in that the Son gives life “to whom he will” and to them alone.
ii. This would appear to be both an allusion to the electing mercies of God and to the sovereignty of the Son to heal (like the paralytic) or not to heal as he wills, remembering that he has said that he only does what the Father is doing, so even the electing graces of Christ are consistent with and flow from the Father. Trinitarian theology is richer than gold.
- 5:22 All judgment is given to the Son. This is remarkable for the Father to relegate all Judicial action to the Son of God alone.
- 5:23 The giving of judgment to the Son was so that all may honor him.
i. The connection between honor to the Son and honor to the Father is established. Just as no one can be received by the Son unless the Father give him (and many statements of similar point).
ii. 5:24 This is the giving of Eternal Life by the Son, to those who hear his voice and believe him (the Father) who sent the Son.
- They are delivered from death unto life. The physical resurrections are a down-payment of the spiritual life-giving of the Son.
- 5:25 The promise of resurrection by “the Son of God.”
i. The “Son of God” is rarely used in the John. But here Christ speaks of himself in this language.
ii. Belief in the Son of God gives eternal life. Those who hear the voice of the Son of God will live.
- 5:26 The Father has life in himself, he gives his same self-generating life, to the Son. The Son is not dependent on the Father for his life, but the Father have given the Son the authority to have life in himself, just as the Father has life in himself. Again, difficult, wonderful, Trinitarian doctrine given by Christ as he describes his own life with the Father and how this life is sustained from eternity and to eternity.
- 5:27 The authority to execute judgment is the Father’s but he gives this authority to the Son.
- 5:28 Resurrection of life and resurrection of judgment.
- 5:30 –36 The witnesses to Jesus, from John the Baptist (the last and greatest prophet, whom the Jews rejected) and from God the Father.
i. The conflict and the confrontation are set up in this section.
ii. Notice the many uses of “witness” through this section.
iii. This leads to Jesus turning to the Jews and charging them that they do not believe 5:37ff.
- Confrontation with the Jews about Jesus’work and Person.
- 5:37 The Father has borne testimony to the Son but the Jews have not understood (remember the prologue of the Gospel, John 1:11, “he came to his own, but his own did not receive him.”
- 5:38 “and you do not have this word abiding in you.”
- 5:39 – 45 The Jews thought that through the Scriptures they would have eternal life, but it was the Scriptures (Moses) who condemned them.
i. They did not have the “love of God within” them (5:42) .
ii. He has come in his Father’s name, yet they do not receive him (5:43).
iii. They receive glory from one another, not from God (5:44).
iv. Jesus doesn’t have to accuse them, Moses is the one who indicts them (5:45).
- The prophetic words of Moses predicted the coming of Messiah, the Christ, and Moses wrote about Jesus (5:46).
- They are beyond believing in Christ because they did not believe Moses’ writing, therefore they could not receive him (4:47).








